neyronrose (neyronrose) wrote,

switching types of romance

Following this on Desert Island Keepers (, where a reader, LesleyW, is explaining how she went from reading m/f romances -- or straight romances, as I call them -- to m/m romances. I think I've seen LesleyW commenting on various blogs I read, and on the m/m romance fans group. I believe she's one of the people who is also avidly following Alles Was Zahlt, too. I still read some m/f romance, though probably quite a bit less than m/m romance at this point.. There are some authors who write strong female characters. No, let me specify further. There are some authors who write strong female characters who are not overbearing and annoying. Jayne Castle/Jayne Ann Krentz/Amanda Quick writes some good ones. Also, as of this century, or perhaps the 1990s, the men in her stories are more willing to communicate and less overbearing as well. Some of the ones from the 1980s had heroes who spanked the heroines when they thought the heroines were misbehaving. Not in the way spanking is now portrayed as a fun, sexy thing, but as a punishment and humiliation done against the woman's will. It didn't really occur to me to have a problem with that whole concept when I was sixteen, but now that I'm approaching forty, I wonder how I ever could have believed that the women would forgive the men for that.

Thinking of all the books I've read lately that have spanking as random fun, I wander completely off the original topic...I like reading about some Dom/sub relationships, if I think they're done well, but I generally prefer the m/m relationships of that type. The submissive women in most books like that is portrayed as being even more of a doormat than the traditional romance heroine. Have the writers never heard of anyone being gleefully submissive? It doesn't even seem like the woman is enjoying it half the time, and if she is shown enjoying it, I'm usually wondering what's going on in her head for her to enjoy it. Characterization problems?

And for femme Doms? We're back to the overbearing and annoying, with usually bad D/s dynamics. It generally seems like she's just doing things on a whim, and is totally untrained. Meanwhile, the men have become the doormats, and take everything the woman says seriously, even if she's saying stupid and/or irrational things. I like those rare romances in which the characters give each other reality checks. Not necessarily in an evil way -- it can be gentle.

There are stories in which the hero and heroine work together. Stories where there's actual communication, and they work things out like grownups. I haven't given up m/f romance, I'm not squicked by it, and I don't usually rant about "girl cooties" being in a book, with the exception of books which have a woman randomly thrown into a male couple's perfectly good relationship. I don't think it's necessary to throw the woman in there at all, although I understand why it might be a fantasy for some women.

Will get back to this...
Tags: rambling, reading

  • Wednesday so far

    I went to bed at 1:00 a.m. and woke at 10:20 a.m. I read The Mechanical Chrysanthemums. A few hours later: Mom and I went to get spring water. We…

  • Monday so far

    I conked out around 1:00 a.m. and got up a little before 10:00 a.m. The Big Gay Fiction Giveaway is back.…

  • Sunday

    I conked out at 10:00 p.m. and woke at 10:00 a.m. I reread some more of the Whybourne and Griffin books. I texted with J., WhiteSheepCBD and A.…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded